Scary October?

By Paul Nolte

Weekly Newsletter: October 5, 2026

“It’s a long way from May to December, but the days grow short when you reach September.” A musical version of “sell in May and go away”. Over the past few years, that strategy has not worked out that well, as the markets advanced nearly 3% from this past May’s high point. Not record-breaking, but a respectable gain. As the weather has gotten chillier, so too have the markets. The net number of advancing to declining stocks has been negative for the past two months, and stocks making new yearly highs have been dwarfed by those making new yearly lows. The economy has cooled a bit too, if the employment report was taken at face value. New job creation was well below expectations, and the unemployment rate got rounded up to 4.2% from 4.1%. Even many of the Fed Governors in their speeches last week highlighted what they saw as a strong, but not strengthening, economy, with little need for another rate increase. As a result, expectations for said increase have dropped from over 60% to under 30% when the Fed meets later this month. Of course, that may change when the inflation data is reported mid-month. As the calendar flips from one of the worst months of the year, investors took heed and pushed stocks up to welcome in October. Strong corporate earnings, centering more on the AI-related companies, have been supportive of stocks all year. Earnings season gets started in another week, and investors will get a fresh look at how companies are doing, but also the capital spending plans for the hyperscalers, which may drive the markets into the Thanksgiving holiday.

It seems there is always a “yes, but” attached to most economic releases. That is true of the jobs data released this past Friday. Headlines look rough: higher unemployment, worse-than-expected job gains, and prior months were revised lower. The glass-half-full argument is that the average job gains of 40k/mo. over the past twelve months is the fastest in a year. For much of 2024 and 2025, those revisions now are now much less negative and may flip positive by year-end. Wage gains are running very close to headline inflation, and well above core. Yes, oil remains at the heart of the discussion when talking about inflation. Reviewing the manufacturing surveys, the prices paid component is at its highest levels since coming out of Covid. This may be an indication of the spreading out of inflation beyond oil prices. It is investors’ fear that growth may slow while inflation remains a problem, the classic stagflation scenario. So far, there is little evidence of a slowing economy, whether looking at GDP growth, durable goods orders, and, yes, the jobs data. Many see the economy as strong, but maybe not strengthening. A nuance that may instruct the Fed at their next meeting.

The bond market is struggling mightily with energy prices, debt issuance, and a strong economy. Rates on 2-year Treasuries nearly broke above 5%, before finishing out the week below 4.9%. Yields have been rising in lockstep with higher energy prices, with fears that inflation will be in the economy much longer than most currently believe. Competition for investment dollars is heating up too, as corporate debt issuance has jumped, fueled primarily by the tech sector. As more debt comes to market, the higher the yield needs to be for investors to buy. Finally, investors may be signaling they are concerned about corporate debt. Yield differences between corporate and Treasury yields have jumped over the past month to their highest levels since the start of the Iran war.

The markets continue to rise, even as worries about inflation and higher bond yields raise concerns about the economy. Driven in large part by the tech sector, September was a rough month for the average stock. They fell nearly 5%, while the “averages” held steady. Small stocks, the darlings early in the year, also fell by 5%. The “broadening out” of the markets reversed aggressively last month as only one of the eleven sectors within the SP500 finished positive (tech). Seasonally, the period beginning in October and running through June in midterm election years tends to be very positive. The only caution would be that the markets have already experienced tremendous gains over the past 2½ years, with valuations near the top of their historical range. Disappointing earnings, AI “issues,” or slowing economic growth could set the market up for a meaningful drop. As always, the timing of that drop is never evident in advance.

The first full week of October will be a bit quieter ahead of inflation data and the start of earnings season on the 14th. Fed speakers and Fed minutes may take center stage this week.

The opinions expressed in the Investment Newsletter are those of the author and are based upon information that is believed to be accurate and reliable but are opinions and do not constitute a guarantee of present or future financial market conditions.

More Insights

Are you ready to leave uncertainty in the past?

We’re excited to learn more about you and to start building a plan for your financial future. The first step is to schedule a meeting with us.

Or call us at 214-373-8362